Why does my trailer sway?

Sway isn't one problem. When it happens — every mile, only on the way home, only when a truck passes — tells you which cause you have, and each one has a reading you can take.

Trailer sway has a handful of causes: tongue weight, speed, wind, tires and the hitch. They leave different fingerprints. A light tongue sways from the first mile, a shifted load sways on the way home, and wind sways when trucks pass and then settles. Find your row, take the reading, and the fix follows. The table prints as a card for the glovebox.

Why does a light tongue make a trailer sway?

A trailer's own tires are what straighten it. Push the back of the trailer sideways and the tires resist; if the trailer's weight sits well forward of them, that resistance swings the trailer back into line and the swing dies out. Move the weight back toward the axles and the same nudge overshoots, swings back and overshoots again. Above a certain speed each swing is bigger than the last. That speed is the one that matters, and tongue weight sets it.

Top view of a pickup towing a travel trailer, twice. Above, with tongue weight in the 10 to 15% band, the trailer is barely turned on the ball and a small arc shows the swing dying out. Below, with under 10%, the trailer is turned further and a wider arc shows each swing growing.
The 10%–15% band drawn here is the US convention for travel trailers; where a swing starts to grow depends on speed as well as tongue weight, as the Bath tests below show.
What the test track says

A University of Bath study (Darling, Tilley and Gao, 2009) ran 600 tests with a Ford Mondeo estate towing a purpose-built, fully adjustable trailer, set up to match a typical British touring trailer: 877 kg with a 52.4 kg nose mass, 5.97% of its weight. The car held a straight line at 30 to 60 mph, the driver started a swing with a steering input, and from how fast each swing died away the authors estimated the speed at which it would stop dying away at all. Less nose weight lowered that speed: "a nose mass of less than 2 per cent of the overall trailer mass has a zero damping speed below 60 mile/h." The gain from more nose weight flattened above 6%–7%, and the authors recommend "around 6–8 per cent". Yaw inertia (weight far from the trailer's middle), nose weight and the axle position were the dominant factors; by the abstract's account, "the trailer mass alone does not dramatically affect the high-speed stability". A longer hitch-to-axle distance helped, and higher tire pressure helped a little.

The 6%–8% figure is for European touring trailers. The US convention for travel trailers is 10%–15%, which sits above where the Bath curve flattens, and the margin covers a loaded rear bumper, water that moves during a trip, and a tongue nobody has weighed.

That's why the band's low edge is the one to respect. A tongue at 16% makes a truck squat and steer light, which is uncomfortable; a tongue at 8% makes the trailer the thing that decides where you go. The tongue-weight calculator measures it with a bathroom scale and a board, and shows how far moving cargo shifts it.

Why did it tow fine on the way there and sway on the way home?

Because the trailer you drove home isn't the one you weighed. On most travel trailers the fresh tank sits near or ahead of the axles and the gray and black tanks sit behind them, under a rear bathroom. A week of camping moves every gallon of water from one to the others, backward, and then the firewood and bikes go on the bumper. Here is a 30 ft trailer, 7,000 lb with an 840 lb tongue when it left home, axles 21 ft behind the coupler:

Trip stageTrailerTongueTongue %
Leaving home, weighed: fresh tank full7,000 lb840 lb12.0% in band
Fresh tank drained (45 gal used)6,625 lb769 lb11.6% in band
…into the gray tank (30 gal)6,875 lb697 lb10.1% in band
…and the black tank (15 gal)7,000 lb649 lb9.3% light
Firewood and bikes on the bumper (120 lb)7,120 lb598 lb8.4% light
At the dump station: gray and black dumped, bumper load into the truck6,625 lb769 lb11.6% in band

Each row applies one change to the row above: tongue change = weight × its distance ahead of (+) or behind (−) the axles ÷ 21 ft. Fresh tank centered 4 ft ahead of the axles, gray 6 ft and black 8 ft behind, bumper 9 ft behind; water 8.34 lb/gal. Look under your own trailer: tank positions vary by floor plan.

The trailer ends the week at 8.4%, below the band without anything having gone wrong. The fix at the dump station costs nothing: dump both tanks and move the bumper load into the truck bed, and it's back to 11.6%. If you're heading to the next campsite rather than home, carry the water you'll need in the fresh tank, which sits forward, and dump the rest.

Same weight on the scale, 191 lb less on the ball

Once the 45 gallons have moved from the fresh tank to the gray and black tanks, the trailer weighs exactly what it did leaving home, 7,000 lb, and its tongue has dropped from 840 lb to 649 lb, 12.0% to 9.3%. A CAT scale ticket from the start of the trip would show a trailer "within its ratings" on the day it swayed. Weight behind the axles also counts twice: it takes load off the tongue and adds to the trailer weight the percentage is taken of.

Why does my trailer sway when a semi passes?

A truck passing at speed pushes a wall of air ahead of it and drags a low-pressure pocket behind: your trailer gets shoved away, then pulled in, in about a second. A travel trailer is a tall, flat sail, so the side force is large and it lands at the back, where it has the most leverage. A well-loaded trailer twitches and settles in two or three swings. One that keeps swinging after the truck has gone is telling you the trailer was already near its limit; the truck only started it. Crosswinds do the same thing without the truck, and the common advice is to park once gusts reach 20–25 mph. Sway control (a friction bar, or the friction or cam built into a weight-distribution head) adds damping against exactly this, and the weight-distribution page says whether your trailer should have it. If a swing does build, the trailer brake lever on the controller (step three on the card) pulls the trailer back into line, which only works if the controller's gain is set; the brake controller page covers setting it.

Will a sway bar fix trailer sway?

Friction sway control resists the trailer pivoting on the ball, which damps a swing started by wind and is useful on any high-sided trailer. It buys a few miles an hour. In the Bath tests a friction stabilizer on a less stable setup raised the speed where swings stop dying out from 61 to 66 mph, and the authors' advice was still to drive at a sensible speed with one fitted. With the tongue at 8%, a bar also hides the warning: the trailer can feel planted right up to the speed where the bar is overwhelmed, and then the swing arrives with no build-up, because the margin was never there. Load the trailer right first, then add sway control for the wind. Hitches that control sway with geometry (the Hensley Arrow and the ProPride 3P) use a linkage that moves the trailer's pivot point forward from the ball, toward the truck's rear axle; Hensley describes a "Virtual Pivot Point" over it. They're the answer for a rig that's already loaded and matched correctly and still unsettled, not for one that isn't.

Is it the truck, not the trailer?

Three causes on the truck side feel like sway from behind the wheel:

  • A light front axle. Hang the tongue on the ball and the truck pivots on its rear axle: the rear squats and the front lifts, taking grip off the wheels that steer. Truck makers ask a weight-distribution hitch to put 50%–100% of that front-axle load back; a tape measure on the front fender is the driveway check.
  • Soft tires. Truck tires below the door-placard pressure, or passenger-car (P-metric) tires carrying a tongue, let the rear of the truck squirm, and the trailer follows it. Check cold, before the drive.
  • Too much trailer. A trailer over about 50% of the truck's weight, or a truck with a short wheelbase and a long overhang behind the rear axle, gives the trailer the leverage. The towing checks test payload and axle ratings, where a rig like this usually fails first.

What speed is safe to tow a travel trailer?

Two hard numbers bound it. Trailer (ST) tires are rated for 65 mph unless the sidewall carries a higher speed rating (Goodyear publishes a higher-pressure exception for its Marathon up to 75 mph; check the tire maker's guidance for your tire and wheel), and California's limit for anything towing a trailer is 55 mph. Under those, the safe speed is below the one where your rig starts to sway, with room to spare, and on most rigs that's lower than the speed limit. If your trailer sways at 68 every time, 68 is your rig's number until you fix the tongue, because a light tongue brings that number down.

Sources

  1. An experimental investigation of car–trailer high-speed stability, J. Darling, D. Tilley and B. Gao, University of Bath; Proc. IMechE Part D 223(4), 2009, pp. 471–484, DOI 10.1243/09544070JAUTO981: 600 tests on an adjustable trailer set up like a typical British touring trailer; zero-damping speed against nose mass, yaw inertia, axle position and a friction stabilizer
  2. Hensley Arrow vs. Pro Pride 3P: Key Hitch Differences, Hensley Manufacturing: the maker’s description: a four-bar linkage that moves the trailer’s pivot point forward, to a virtual pivot over the truck’s rear axle