How long does a 6-gallon RV water heater last in the shower?
About 5.3 minutes with the water running, on spring water through a normal RV showerhead. The usual answer of five to ten minutes spreads that wide because of two numbers, the inlet temperature and the showerhead. The tank holds 130 °F water but you shower at 105, so the valve mixes: on 55 °F inlet water the mix is 67% hot, and a 1.5 gpm showerhead pulls 1.00 gpm from the tank. Only about 70% of a tank comes out hot before the incoming cold has mixed the rest lukewarm, 4.2 gallons of a 6, and the burner is putting 0.20 gpm of hot back while you stand there. So 4.2 ÷ (1.00 − 0.20) = 5.3 minutes, 7.9 gallons of shower. By inlet water:
| Tank, on gas | Summer hose · 70 °F | Spring / fall · 55 °F | Cold well water · 40 °F |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6 gal | 6.7 min running · 2.4 navy showers | 5.3 min running · 2.1 navy showers | 4.6 min running · 1.9 navy showers |
| 10 gal | 11.2 min running · 4 navy showers | 8.8 min running · 3.5 navy showers | 7.6 min running · 3.2 navy showers |
1.5 gpm showerhead, tank at 130 °F, shower at 105 °F, 70% of the tank usable, 12,000 BTU/h burner at 63% putting hot back during the shower. A navy shower is 3 gal of mixed water. On the 6-gallon tank at 55 °F, a 2.0 gpm head cuts the running shower to 3.7 minutes and a 1.0 gpm low-flow head stretches it to 9 minutes.
The navy-shower column is the boondocking number: two people can shower back to back from a hot 6-gallon tank on spring water, and the tank is ready for a third after 9.9 minutes on gas. The boondocking-days calculator counts the fresh water those showers drink.
How long does an RV water heater take to heat up?
A gallon needs 8.34 BTU per degree. Six gallons from 55 to 130 °F is 3,753 BTU. Suburban's 6-gallon SW6D burns 12,000 BTU/h and gets about 7,560 of it into the water; the 1,440 W element on the SW6DE delivers 4,569 BTU/h, and with both on they add:
| From 55 °F to 130 | Gas | Electric | Both | After one navy shower (gas) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6 gal | 29.8 min | 49.3 min | 18.6 min | 9.9 min |
| 10 gal | 49.6 min | 82.1 min | 30.9 min | 9.9 min |
Efficiencies from Suburban's tank water heater specifications, which list the 12,000 BTU/h SW6D at 10.1 gal/h on gas and the 1,440 W element at 6.1 gal/h (the 10-gallon SW10D burns the same 12,000). The sheet doesn't state the temperature rise; at the 90 °F rise this page assumes, those work out to 63% and 93%. Colder inlet water adds minutes in proportion to the rise.
That covers most of the gas-or-electric question. The element is slower, free on a bundled pedestal, and 12 A of a 30 A service that the air conditioner also wants. Gas is faster and costs 0.022 gal of propane a navy shower. Both together is fastest. On hookups run both; off-grid the element has nothing to run on.
A tank heater is a bucket with the cold inlet at the bottom and the hot outlet at the top. As you draw hot water, cold water enters underneath and the two mix at the boundary; by the time 70% of the tank has left, what's coming out of the top is a blend below shower temperature even though the tank is "full." That is the 0.7 first-hour-delivery factor RV sellers quote, and it is why a 6-gallon heater is a 4.2-gallon heater for shower arithmetic. The burner offsets some of it, 0.20 gpm of hot on gas, which is also why a running shower gets a few extra minutes that a bath would not.
Will an RV tankless water heater keep up with a shower?
A tankless unit never runs out, but it can only lift the water so many degrees at a given flow: BTU/h = gpm × 60 × 8.34 × rise. The Girard GSWH-2 and Furrion F2GWH are both rated 42,000 BTU/h. At 80%, this page's assumption since neither maker publishes a thermal efficiency, that delivers 33,600 BTU/h. To reach 105 °F from 55 °F water that allows 1.34 gpm, less than the showerhead, so at 1.5 gpm the water arrives at 99.8 °F. The unit is working as designed; it is temperature-limited, and turning the tap down is the fix:
| Inlet water | 42,000 BTU/h: at 1.5 gpm | max gpm at 105 °F | 55,000 BTU/h: at 1.5 gpm | max gpm |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 70 °F | 115 °F ✓ | 1.92 gpm | 129 °F ✓ | 2.51 gpm |
| 55 °F | 100 °F, 5.2 short | 1.34 gpm | 114 °F ✓ | 1.76 gpm |
| 40 °F | 85 °F, 20.2 short | 1.03 gpm | 99 °F, 6.4 short | 1.35 gpm |
80% thermal efficiency is this site's planning figure; the makers publish input ratings only. 105 °F shower. Girard and Furrion both state a minimum of 0.80 gpm per hot faucet (Girard's controller starts at about 0.90), and the Truma AquaGo lights above about 1.5 liters a minute, 0.40 gpm. Below that the flame drops out, so a navy shower's "water off, soap up" restarts the burner each time, and the cold slug that follows is the "cold sandwich."
So at 42,000 BTU/h a tankless unit is a summer-and-south appliance, and at 55,000 an all-season one, as is a 42,000 unit with a low-flow head. Truma's AquaGo modulates from 20,000 to 60,000 BTU/h, so at full fire it does a little better than the 55,000 column, and it aims for a 120 °F outlet. On the propane side a 42,000 unit burns 0.46 gal/h only while water runs, 0.061 gal for an 8-minute shower, and nothing on standby.
How much propane does an RV water heater use?
A navy shower on gas is 0.022 gal of propane at 55 °F inlet. The other ways to shower, and a crew of four over a week:
| Per shower | Propane | Electricity | Four a day, 7 days |
|---|---|---|---|
| Navy shower on the tank, gas (3 gal) | 0.022 gal | n/a | 0.61 gal |
| Navy shower on the tank, electric | n/a | 0.39 kWh | 11 kWh |
| 5-minute running shower on the tank, gas | 0.054 gal | n/a | 1.52 gal |
| 8-minute running shower, tankless | 0.061 gal | n/a | 1.71 gal |
| Tank left on, standby (gas) | 0.118 gal/day | n/a | 0.83 gal |
55 °F inlet, tank at 130 °F. Standby: no RV maker publishes a standby loss, so this page borrows the federal ceiling for commercial gas storage water heaters in 10 CFR 431.110, Q/800 + 110√V BTU/h, as a stand-in. For the 12,000 BTU/h, 6-gallon tank that is 284 BTU/h lost from the water, replaced at 63%: a gallon of propane every 8.4 days for a heater left lit. A 20 lb cylinder is 4.7 gal; the propane calculator adds the furnace, fridge and stove.
A week of four navy showers a day is 0.61 gal of propane. Leaving the same tank lit for the week is 0.83 gal of standby loss on the stand-in figure above, 1.4× the showers. Light it 29.8 minutes before the first shower and switch it off after the last, and the standby line drops out. On hookups, the element does the standby for free and the gas does the recovery when the crew lines up.
Should you run an RV water heater on gas, electric, both or tankless?
On a pedestal, run the element all the time and add gas when a queue forms, after checking the pedestal. The element is 12 A continuous, and on 30 A with a 13,500 BTU air conditioner it is the pair that trips the breaker when the microwave starts. The result panel runs that check against your rig, and the shore-power calculator runs it with everything else on the circuit. Off-grid: gas, lit before the showers and off after. Tankless: buy the BTU for the coldest water you camp in rather than the length of the rig, and fit a 1.0 gpm showerhead, which on 55 °F water raises a 42,000 unit's outlet by 22 °F for the price of a showerhead. When the season ends, the tank gets drained and bypassed before any antifreeze goes in; the winterizing calculator shows what skipping that step costs.
Sources
- Direct Spark Ignition Porcelain Lined, Steel Tank Water Heaters, 6 Gallon, Suburban: SW6D: 12,000 BTU/h, 10.1 gal/h recovery on gas; 1,440 W element, 6.1 gal/h
- Porcelain Steel Tank Water Heater Specifications, Suburban: gas input and recovery for the 4 to 16 gallon tanks
- 10 CFR 431.110, Energy conservation standards and their effective dates, U.S. Department of Energy, Code of Federal Regulations (2023): maximum standby loss of a commercial gas storage water heater, Q/800 + 110√V BTU/h
- Owner’s Manual, Model GSWH-2, Girard Products: 42,000 BTU/h; a minimum of 0.80 gpm per hot faucet
- Tankless Water Heater Model F2GWH User Manual, Furrion: 42,000 BTU/h; a minimum of 0.80 gpm per hot faucet
- Product info Truma AquaGo instant water heater, Truma: 20,000 to 60,000 BTU/h; the burner starts above about 1.5 L per minute; 120 °F outlet